Reviewer Selection & Membership Criteria

Reviewer Selection & Membership Criteria:

To maintain the highest scholarly standards, Ibn Sina University Journal relies on a distinguished pool of experts and academics. Peer reviewers are meticulously selected based on the following rigorous criteria:

1. Professional and Ethical Standards:

  • Integrity and Objectivity: Reviewers must demonstrate absolute honesty, scientific integrity, and total impartiality throughout the evaluation.

  • Punctuality: A strict commitment to completing the review process and submitting reports within the definitive deadlines set by the Editorial Board.

  • Specialized Expertise: Full mastery of a narrow scientific specialty and staying consistently current with its latest advancements and literature.

  • Academic Rank and Experience: Reviewers must hold the academic rank of (Assistant Professor) or higher and possess a proven track record of reviewing at least 10 manuscripts for peer-reviewed scholarly journals.

  • Constructive Feedback: The proven ability to provide precise, professional, and constructive critiques that effectively assist authors in elevating the quality of their work.

  • Confidentiality: Strict, uncompromised adherence to the journal’s privacy policy and double-blind peer review protocols.

2. Cooperation and Partnerships:

  • The journal officially recognizes and utilizes the accredited reviewers’ registry from the Libyan Association for E-Learning.

  • Accredited reviewers are fully entitled to benefit from the various academic services, privileges, and recognitions offered by the journal in appreciation of their valuable scholarly contributions.

  • All official editorial communications and correspondence are strictly facilitated through the publisher's official channels and platforms.

3. Membership and Certification Requirements:

Applicants wishing to officially join the review board and obtain an accredited reviewer certificate must provide:

  • An updated, comprehensive, and detailed Curriculum Vitae (CV).

  • Active links to professional profiles on established academic platforms: (Google Scholar, ResearchGate, Scopus).

  • Valid personal identification along with official academic credentials and certifications.